As the holiday season approaches, many teachers find themselves contemplating whether to deck their classroom halls with Christmas cheer. I myself love the holiday season! In my teaching career across various public schools, I’ve experienced a wide range of Christmas-themed activities: music concerts, Breakfasts with Santa, Christmas movie nights, themed plays, door decorating contests, caroling, fundraisers, and staff parties. These activities were common in schools with predominantly Christian populations, and at the time, I never questioned whether we might be excluding families with different traditions.

While Christmas is a national holiday in Canada and these festive activities can create a joyful atmosphere, they also raise important questions about inclusivity and appropriateness in public schools. Given that we live in an increasingly multicultural society, filled with people from diverse cultural backgrounds, religions, and traditions, it’s crucial to reflect on our practices.

Some argue that Christmas celebrations in schools are a cherished tradition and part of Canadian culture. Others contend that public schools should be neutral spaces that respect all beliefs equally. Let’s explore both sides of this debate, considering how we can create inclusive environments while respecting various cultural traditions.

Is Christmas a religious holiday?

Christmas has both religious and secular aspects:

Religious Aspects:

1. Commemoration of Jesus Christ’s birth
2. Celebration of God’s incarnation
3. Church services on Christmas Eve or Christmas Day
4. Use of Christian imagery in decorations
5. Biblical narratives from the Gospels

Secular Aspects:

1. Widely celebrated cultural holiday
2. Traditions like gift-giving, tree decorating, and family gatherings
3. Federal holiday status in many countries
4. Secular figures like Santa Claus
5. Focus on generosity and togetherness

While Christmas remains an important religious holiday for Christians, it has also evolved to include significant secular and cultural traditions that are celebrated more broadly. Its status can be seen as both religious and secular, depending on how it is observed by different individuals and communities.

Pros of Christmas Decorations and Crafts

1. Fostering Holiday Spirit

Decorating classrooms and engaging in Christmas crafts can create a warm, festive atmosphere that many students find exciting and enjoyable. It can help build a sense of community and shared experience among students who celebrate Christmas.

2. Cultural Learning Opportunity

For students unfamiliar with Christmas traditions, decorations and crafts can serve as a learning experience about different cultural practices.

3. Creativity and Skill Development

Christmas-themed crafts can be an excellent way to develop fine motor skills, encourage creativity, and teach art techniques in a fun, seasonal context.

4. Connecting School and Home

For students who celebrate Christmas, seeing familiar decorations and participating in related activities can help bridge the gap between home and school environments.

Cons of Christmas Decorations and Crafts

1. Exclusion of Non-Christian Students

Focusing solely on Christmas can make students from other religious or cultural backgrounds feel excluded or marginalized. This is especially important in diverse classrooms.

2. Distraction from Learning

Excessive decorations or time spent on holiday crafts might take away from valuable instructional time, especially during a busy academic period.

3. Emotional Challenges for Some Students

For students facing difficult personal circumstances, constant reminders of holiday cheer can be emotionally challenging.

4. Risk of religious symbolism

While secular symbols like Christmas trees may be acceptable, overtly religious symbols like nativity scenes are generally not appropriate for public school displays. Even attempts at inclusive displays can inadvertently favor one tradition over others or send unintended messages about religious preferences.

Finding a Balance

If you decide to incorporate Christmas elements in your classroom, consider these inclusive approaches:

1. Embrace Winter Themes: Focus on general winter motifs like snowflakes, snowmen, and winter landscapes that aren’t specific to any holiday.
2. Multicultural Approach: Include decorations and crafts from various cultural celebrations occurring around the same time, such as Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, or Diwali.
3. Educational Focus: If addressing holidays, do so from an educational perspective, teaching about various traditions rather than celebrating a specific one.
4. Student Choice: Allow students to choose which holiday-themed crafts they want to create, if any, providing options for different traditions or non-holiday alternatives.
5. Secular Symbols: Opt for decorations that focus on secular aspects of the season, like kindness, giving, or winter activities.

Conclusion

While Christmas decorations and crafts can bring joy to many students, it’s crucial to consider the diverse needs and backgrounds of all learners. By taking a thoughtful, inclusive approach, while respecting the cultural significance of the season, we can create a welcoming classroom environment that respects and celebrates diversity during the holiday season.

Remember, the goal is to foster a sense of belonging and joy for all students, regardless of their cultural or religious background. A thoughtful, balanced approach that considers your specific student population is likely the best path forward.

Check out our Free Factsheet & Doodle Bundle!

Our factsheets and doodle notes are designed to help students improve their attention, memory, and creativity. Try our bundle for free!

I want this free bundle!